Posted by SharonSilver in Articles on Tue, Nov 8, 2011
This article is the first in a 3-week series about parenting ideas. This week I’m discussing the differences between reacting and responding, and the importance of putting a new parenting idea to the test.
I did a TV interview last week where the first question asked was, What’s the difference between reacting and responding? (My book is called Stop Reacting and Start Responding: 108 Ways to Discipline Consciously and Become the Parent You Want to Be).
How is “Responding” Different from “Reacting”?
Reacting is caused by the way you’re thinking about your daily life. Reacting ignites the fight or flight response, as I described in my article Why So Many Moms Have Short Fuses. Responding begins in your heart. Responding allows a parent to remain calm and firm at the same time, which is the key to unlocking the “I’m Not Listening Barrier.”
Reacting forces compliance.
Responding wins cooperation.
Reacting is born from anger.
Responding is created from empathy, not sympathy.
Sympathy is feeling sorry for a child, empathy acknowledges the feelings a child has about getting busted for the misbehavior, yet still insists that a correction
Reacting skips over the emotions a child has about the situation.
Responding addresses the emotions that caused the misbehavior in the first place.
Reacting doesn’t address the needs of the situation-it uses punishment.
Responding fully focuses on the needs of the situation showing parents what a child needs to learn.
Reacting usually causes a parent to have to apologize for behaving badly.
Responding require a child to apologize because they’re the only ones that misbehaved.
Reacting repeats the parenting methods of past generations.
Responding is a new way to parent that uses calm, yet firm techniques that create balanced parenting.
Trying Out a New Parenting Technique
I know you know what the difference between reading and applying a parenting technique is, but the depth of what you’ll find when you apply a new technique is so valuable that I wanted to mention it.
When you read about a parenting technique you use your logical mind, intellect, and reasoning to tell you if this will make sense in your family. Reading about something can cause you to miss valuable “a-ha” moments that could potentially transform your parenting for years to come.
When you apply a parenting technique you get to experience how the method actually works for your family. !Experiencing how a new method (like responding) works, means you don’t miss a thing. What worked and what didn’t work is evident because you’re actually calm enough to recognize which clues and keys caused your child to listen, cooperate and blossom right in front of you.
Applying will also help you:
• Find ways to talk to your child so she feels truly heard,
• Hear the difference between your angry voice and your calm yet firm voice, as you correct behavior,
• See what triggers you about your child’s misbehavior, what lights you up like a Christmas tree and causes you to react,
• Create ways to communicate dialog that will strengthen the parent/child bond.
Next week’s article will discuss the difference between discipline and punishment. In week three I’ll discuss the different kinds of praise.
About Sharon Silver
Sharon Silver is the author of Stop Reacting and Start Responding: 108 Ways to Discipline Consciously and Become the Parent You Want to Be, and the founder of Proactive Parenting. Her book and site help parents gain more patience by responding instead of reacting for ages 1-10. Receive 2 FREE tips from the book. Proactive Parenting is proud to announce the Online Skills Class. A class that any parent can attend, even if you live outside the US. Find her on Twitter and Facebook.